By Werner Gerber, CFA® | Founder, ClearGauge Wealth

ClearGauge Wealth (Pty) Ltd is an Authorised Financial Services Provider (FSP No. 55826).

Last fact-checked: 8 August 2026

Quick Answer

In brief A living annuity and a guaranteed annuity can do different jobs in a retirement-income plan. A combination can be used to compare certainty for some income with flexibility for other income. It is not automatically better than using one arrangement. The right question is what each expense needs from the plan.

Visual Summary

Note General education only. Product terms, guarantees, fees and access differ by provider and contract.

Income question	Living annuity	Guaranteed annuity
Who carries key risks?	The customer carries investment and long-life risk.	The insurer may carry specified risks, subject to the contract.
How can income change?	Income is linked to the account, drawdown choice and investment return.	Income features depend on the contract and escalation terms.
What should be checked?	Drawdown, fund mix, fees and annual review rules.	Guarantee terms, spouse benefits, escalation, capital and access rules.

Decision Framework

1. Start With the Income Job, Not the Product Name

List must-pay costs. Housing, food, medical costs, care and basic transport often belong here. Then list costs that can change. Travel, gifts, upgrades and some leisure costs may have more room to move. This check shows the job of each rand of income. Check product terms after that.

Next, list steady income. This may include a pension, rent or work income. Subtract it from must-pay costs. Check the gap with care. Choose a product after this cash plan. Put the cash plan first.

2. Compare the Contract Terms Before the Headline Income

A stated income is one part of an annuity choice. Check if it rises, stays level or follows another rule. Check what happens if a spouse dies. Check for capital value. Check fees and if a change can be made later. A higher starting income can have other trade-offs.

For a living annuity, check drawdown, fund choice, fees and the next change date. For a guaranteed annuity, read the income terms. Check income increases, spouse benefit, guarantee period and any once-off choice. Products with the same first-year income can still have very different long-term results.

3. Test a Weak Market and a Long Life

The ASISA Standard on Living Annuities says customers carry investment and longevity risk. The income is not guaranteed. It rests on life span, drawdown and investment results. Test a living-annuity plan for weak early markets and a long retirement.

A guaranteed annuity can pass stated risks to an insurer. Its terms still matter. Do not label one choice safe and the other risky. Both have trade-offs. Check which risk is carried, by whom, and what it means for must-pay and flexible spending.

Key Concepts

A Combination Is Two Contracts, Not a Third Product

A mix often uses part of retirement money for a living annuity and part for a guaranteed annuity. Each part keeps its own terms, costs and risks. Read both sets of documents. Two product names do not create an answer for you.

This guide separates income jobs. One part of a plan may need more certainty. Another may need more room to change. This is a plan point, not a suggested split. Amounts depend on spending, other income, health, tax, family needs and terms on offer.

Certainty, Flexibility and Capital Are Separate Questions

It is easy to treat certainty, access and growth as one issue. They are not. An income feature may give more certainty but less access. A market-linked account may give more freedom but leave more risk with the customer. Before choosing a contract, state the trade-off that matters most for each income need.

That is why a mix is not a default answer. A person with sure income from other sources may see the trade-offs differently. So may someone whose retirement account must cover all basic costs. The facts set the questions. A fixed split cannot do that work.

Compare Income at Several Dates

A good check looks at cash flow now and later. Write stated income in year one, after prices rise and after markets fall. List tax and fees on their own. Show any guaranteed-income rise rule. Show when living-annuity income rests on account value and a new election. This does not predict results. It shows the moving parts.

Also check what happens at death and after death. A spouse benefit, guarantee period or remaining account value can matter. The key question is not which feature has the best label. Ask if the terms support the household goals on paper. This shows what to check before a final choice.

Worked Example

Two Income Jobs, Not a Product Recommendation

Assume a household has a R40,000 monthly gap after other income. In a simple budget exercise, R28,000 may be marked as must-pay costs and R12,000 as flexible costs. The sum is R40,000. Neither amount is assigned to a product. The exercise only separates income jobs before product terms are compared.

Note Illustrative budget only. It uses made-up figures and does not recommend an income source, a product or a split.

Budget layer	Monthly illustration	Question to test
Must-pay costs	R28,000	Which income sources need to hold up in a weak market?
Flexible costs	R12,000	What could change for a period if conditions are poor?
Total gap	R40,000	What do tax, fees and contract terms leave to spend?

The maths is simple. The next step is not. The family still needs to check tax, fees, product terms, inflation, life span and market moves. A budget can make the talk clearer. It cannot choose a contract or predict the outcome.

Reality Check

Gather a current budget, recent statements, other income details and full terms for each annuity quote. Check what is paid after tax and fees, not only gross income. Ask how a spouse or dependant is affected. Check what can change after the decision.

Which costs must continue if investment values fall?
Which income is set, and for how long?
What happens if one spouse dies or needs care?
What capital, if any, remains accessible under each contract?

Check the plan after a major change in spending, health, family needs or other income. The check tests whether the trade-offs still match the facts. It is not a forecast.

Common Mistakes

Using a Percentage Split as a Shortcut

A 50/50 or other split may sound balanced. It leaves the budget and contract terms untested. A percentage cannot know the income gap, tax, life span or other assets. Use a fixed split as a prompt for questions, not an answer.

Comparing Only the First Income Amount

First-year income can hide later differences. Check income increases, spouse benefits, guarantee periods, fees, access, drawdown rules and capital left at death. The best check is not always the biggest first-page number.

Assuming a Guarantee Covers Every Risk

A guarantee has a set scope. Inflation, access, estate goals, tax and the strength of other income can still matter. Read what is guaranteed, for whom, for how long and under which terms.

Treating a Living Annuity Range as Advice

An allowed income range tells you what can be selected. The range alone does not show that the amount will meet a household budget over time. Test drawdown with the whole plan.

What This Framework Does Not Decide

This guide cannot choose an annuity, set a drawdown or decide a product split. It does not provide financial, investment, tax or legal advice. Your goals, finances, needs, health, tax, other income and contract terms may change the answer. Use the framework to prepare for a discussion about a major retirement decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I have both a living annuity and a guaranteed annuity?

A combination may be available, subject to the rules and product terms that apply. Availability does not show a combination is suitable. The income need, contract terms and wider plan still need to be assessed.

Does a guaranteed annuity remove all retirement risk?

A guaranteed annuity may cover stated income and long-life risks under its contract. Inflation, tax, access, estate goals and the amount of other income still need consideration.

Can I change the split later?

The answer depends on the contracts and the decision already made. Some choices may be hard or impossible to reverse. Check this before acting. Confirm whether flexibility will remain.

How should the two annuities be compared?

Compare the job each income source must do. Then read the full terms. Include income timing, increases, fees, access, spouse benefits, capital treatment, tax and the risks carried by each party.

Financial Clarity Review

A practical next step

If an annuity decision is major, bring the budget, annuity quotes, product terms, latest statements and other-income details to a Financial Clarity Review. The talk can split income jobs from product features and make trade-offs clear. It does not promise an outcome or replace advice where advice is needed.

Continue Exploring

Sources and Further Reading

Primary sources checked on 2 August 2026 Recheck product terms, legal rules and tax treatment before acting.

Important Disclosure

General information only

This article is general education. It is not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. The examples use simple assumptions and may not fit your situation. They are not forecasts, promises or recommendations. Investment values can fall or rise. Living-annuity income is not guaranteed and can change. Consider advice suited to your objectives, financial situation and needs before making a major decision.

When this question applies to your own arrangements

See the whole picture before deciding what to change.

A Financial Clarity Review provides an independent view of the arrangements you already have. We first confirm fit, scope and the once-off fee before any work begins.

Request a Financial Clarity Review

Should You Combine a Living Annuity and a Guaranteed Annuity?